top of page

A Closer Look At John Coltrane’s A Love Supreme Part I: Resolution

rbedwell3

This is the second track on the album, also known as Part II and is basically all about one change. The score I am referring to is in F minor, but I know there are many other transcriptions in different keys but the principles here apply to any key it is played in.

The chord progression is as follows:

Fmin6/9 – B (add9)/F# - Gmin7b5 – C7 – F min – C7

Now, firstly, there is a contradiction or mistake to point out. Chord I is F minor 6/9, which is F, Ab C, D and G. The minor 6 designation means a minor chord with a Major 6th, which would imply the Dorian mode and hence the Eb Major scale. But if we look at the score, we can see that the melody over the F minor chord contains a Db, not a D natural, which would mean the mode being played is F Aeolian, mode VI from Ab Major. So, either the designation of minor 6 is wrong and should be minor b6 or there are both notes being played, which I doubt as Dorian and Aeolian are not very compatible, not like Dorian and Melodic for example.

Why does this matter? Well, the change mentioned in the introduction is next, the F min - B (add9)/F# chord. To know what to play over this we have to investigate its origins and as the key is ambiguous, either F Dorian or F Aeolian, we have a choice when it comes to playing over.

1) In F Dorian (Eb Major) we have the notes: Eb F G Ab Bb C D and the B (add9) chord is B D# F# C#. So we can see that the D# is an enharmonic equivalent of Eb, so that is taken care of, which leaves B and F# and C#. Instead of opting for the bland sound of a B Major arpeggio or one from the key it is from, we can work out a suitable scale or two that sounds great based upon music theory. So From Eb Major, we raise the Bb to B and we have C Harmonic minor (C D Eb F G Ab B). Now we raise the F to F# for C Hungarian minor (C D Eb F# G Ab B) and finally raise the C to C# and we have G Persian natural 6 (1 b2 3 4 b5 6 7). So scale choice 1 is G Persian nat6 over B(add9)/F# which would sound modally as its mode VII, Locrian bb36 (scale no. 20). Lovely choice, I really like it. Just learn it in one octave and try playing over the change from F min – B add9.

2) The second choice is more appropriate, in my opinion, as I prefer to think that the melody is in F Aeolian (Ab Major) which is Ab Bb C Db Eb F G. You can see that because there is already a Db in the Ab Major scale, we don’t need to alter the note to reach C# in the chord as this is another enharmonic equivalent. So, the B chord is again B D# F# C# and the Eb = D# while the Db = C#. You can see now that what Coltrane is doing is using enharmonic equivalents to access unusual sounding chords and modes. That leaves B natural and F#.

The next step is is to raise the Bb in Ab Major to get C Neapolitan minor C Db Eb F G Ab B, where the Db = C# and the Eb = D#. Lastly, raising F in C Neapolitan minor gives us C Db Eb F# G Ab B = C Neapolitan minor #4, mode IV of G Persian. Yup, either way we look at it, the best choice is either G Persian or G Persian natural 6, which when played over the B (add9)/F# it sounds as F# Locrian bb367 and Locrian bb36.

Now that you know that, if Resolution is in your repertoire, take a bit of time to learn a Persian scale, and the play around with it over that change. The rest is just straightforward ii - V - i which I am sure you are perfectly fine with. I am working on a solo guitar arrangement of this piece and will post it on my group when it is finished. Thanks for reading.


118 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page